Owners access| Hotel information and booking website unofficial
Sunset Beach, Shelter Island
596US$
Book on our site
Up to 10% less
than Booking.com
Key details
About the Hotel
35 Shore Road,
Shelter Island,
New York,
United States,
11965,
New York State
Sunset Beach is a romantic seaside hideaway on Shelter Island's most idyllic beach. Guests can reach this destination via ferry services from Long Island's North and South Forks. This pet-friendly hotel features modern amenities blended with a casual coastal vibe. The hotel offers personalized services to enhance guest experiences.
Location
Sunset Beach is located 85 km from Long Island MacArthur Airport. Ferry services from Greenport and Sag Harbor provide easy access to Shelter Island. The hotel is within walking distance of local attractions, including art galleries and cultural sites. Guests can navigate the island effortlessly with provided bicycles.
Rooms
Each modern room at Sunset Beach is furnished with hardwood floors and glass-topped tables. Rooms are equipped with an iPod docking station, DVD player, and flat-screen LCD TV. Many rooms feature private terraces with bay views. In-room massages and yoga sessions can also be arranged for guests.
Eat & Drink
Sunset Beach Restaurant and Bar specializes in French cuisine within a casual atmosphere. The venue includes a full-service bar and a curated wine list. Guests can enjoy dining with stunning beach views. Breakfast and light bites are also available throughout the day.
Leisure & Business
Guests can spend their days on the hotel's private beach or explore the island with free bicycle rentals. Yoga sessions are available to promote relaxation. The hotel offers amenities for both leisure and business travelers. In-room massage services are offered to enhance guests' comfort.
View all
Select your room type
The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals
The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences
Wi-Fi
Parking
Luggage storage
24-hour services
General
Wi-Fi
Smoke detectors
Dining
Restaurant
Bar/ Lounge area
Room features
Dressing area
Ironing facilities
Bathroom
Hair dryer
Media
Flat-screen TV
Direct dial telephone
CD player
AM/FM alarm clock
Room decor
Carpeted floor
Show more
Location
35 Shore Road,
Shelter Island,
New York,
United States,
11965,
New York State
Map view
35 Shore Road,
Shelter Island,
New York,
United States,
11965,
New York State
City landmarks
Shelter Island Country Club
690 m
Golf Course
Shelter Island Golf Course
710 m
Shelter Island Tennis Club
900 m
Event hall
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
2.2
km
Church
Our Lady of the Isle Church
1.2
km
Dering Harbor Marina
2.3
km
Amusement Park
Greenport Antique Carousel
3.2
km
Island
Shelter Island
2.3
km
Sylvester Manor
2.2
km
440 4th St at the LIRR Tracks
Railroad Museum of Long Island
2.9
km
Wiggins St Greenport Commercial Pier
Fireboat Firefighter Museum
2.9
km
519 4th St
Congregation Tifereth Israel
3.0
km
Market
The Gatehouse At Sylvester Manor
2.2
km
Front Street Mitchell Park
Camera Obscura
3.1
km
Museum
East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation
3.0
km
Church
Shelter Island Presbyterian Church
2.5
km
3rd St
East End Seaport Maritime Museum
3.5
km
Gallery
Nova Constellatio Gallery
3.4
km
Manhansett Chapel Museum
2.7
km
Harbour
Greenport
3.4
km
Fire Fighter Ship New York
2.9
km
Shelter Island Whale's Tail
2.8
km
Church
Saint Marys Episcopal Church
2.8
km
Long Island Train Museam
2.9
km
Greenport Theatre
3.1
km
Saint Agnes Roman Catholic Church
3.0
km
Gallery
VSOP Art + Design Projects
3.1
km
Museum
Havens House
3.1
km
Nearby
Sunset Beach
220 m
Beach
Crescent Beach
520 m
Restaurants
The Pridwin Restaurant
910 m
81 Shore Road
Reviews and Ratings
Feedback from previous guests about their experience.
78%
liked the hotel and would stay again
7.8/10
Very good
Rooms
7.8
Location
9.0
Service
7.4
Dining
6.6
Guest reviews
7.8/10
based on 5 reviews
8.2
8.2/10based on 8 reviews
William
United States,
February
2024
8.2/10
The hotel offers comfortable and beautiful rooms, with friendly and accommodating service. The location is ideal for the beach, but there are opportunities for improvement in certain areas.
Rooms
8.0
The rooms are not super luxe but are still immaculate, beautiful, and comfortable.
Service
9.0
The service was friendly, professional, and accommodating.
Location
9.0
In this situation, the location is ideal for the beach.
Dining
7.0
The morning dining experience was satisfactory, offering home-made yogurt.
Facilities
8.0
The facilities meet expectations and enhance the overall stay.
Lisa
United States,
December
2023
7.0/10
The hotel has a lovely rustic charm but lacks luxurious touches. The service was extremely helpful, especially with the great beach location, though improvements could be made. The dining experience was satisfactory, and the facilities had some positives and negatives to consider.
Rooms
7.0
The rooms had a rustic charm and were not super luxurious but were lovely and comfortable for a cozy stay.
Service
7.0
The service was extremely helpful, and the beach location made it even better. However, some room and attitude improvements could enhance the overall experience.
Location
9.0
The hotel's location near the beach was great, offering convenient access to the sand and sea for a relaxing stay.
Dining
6.0
The dining experience offered European dishes but could use more variety and improvement for a better overall experience.
Facilities
6.0
The facilities were adequate, though some investments could enhance the overall guest experience for a more pleasant stay.
Stephen
United States,
November
2023
7.6/10
My stay at the hotel was overall pleasant. The rooms, while not super luxurious, were immaculate, beautiful, and comfortable. The service, though a bit disappointing at first, turned around as the manager eventually accommodated our needs. The location, particularly great for the beach, added to the experience. The breakfast in the morning was a bit underwhelming, but the fresh farm-to-table products were a nice touch. The facilities were decent, though not top-notch.
Rooms
8.0
In the past, the rooms were immaculate, beautiful, and comfortable, a little rustic now.
Service
7.0
The manager started off unfriendly and dismissive but eventually helped us out with a suggestion that worked for all.
Location
9.0
In this situation, the location is great for the beach.
Dining
7.0
The morning breakfast was tired, with fresh farm-to-table products.
Facilities
7.0
Decent facilities overall.
Clara
United States,
November
2023
7.6/10
This hotel is a gem! It offers a lovely and cozy atmosphere, ideal for those who appreciate a more rustic charm. While the rooms are not super luxurious, they are comfortable and clean, providing a nice retreat. The service is friendly and welcoming, although some improvements can be made in terms of room maintenance. The location is convenient with easy access to the beach and nearby attractions. The dining experience, although limited, offers some tasty options. Overall, this hotel offers good value for money.
Rooms
8.0
The rooms were lovely - not super luxe but cozy and clean.
Service
7.0
The service was friendly and welcoming, but room maintenance could be improved.
Location
9.0
The location is convenient with easy access to the beach and nearby attractions.
Dining
7.0
The dining experience, although limited, still offered some tasty options.
Facilities
7.0
The facilities are decent, but some maintenance is needed.
Peter
United States,
October
2023
7.4/10
I loved the hotel's rustic charm and comfortable rooms, but some areas need maintenance. The service was accommodating, although improvements could be made with enthusiasm. The location was great, easily accessible down the street. The dining experience was tiring but offers homemade dishes. The facilities are decent, needing some updates for an even better experience.
Rooms
8.0
Immaculate beautiful and comfortable requested rooms.
Service
7.0
The service was friendly, professional, and accommodating, but a bit underenthusiastic at times.
Location
9.0
Great location down the street, offering convenient access.
Dining
6.0
The morning selection was a bit tiring, but the homemade dishes were delightful.
Facilities
7.0
The facilities are good, but some investments could elevate the experience.
Seefelds Bed & Breakfast
Hotel Laaxerhof
Grand Hotel
Hotel Blue
The Cook Hotel & Conference Center
Al Seef Hotel
Oriental Suites Hotel & Spa
Amankila
Emery Hotel, Autograph Collection
Mexico City Marriott Reforma Hotel
Fifteen Beacon Hotel
Oceania Park Hotel Spa & Convention