Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island, Shelter Island

The hotel offers comfortable and beautiful rooms, with friendly and accommodating service. The location is ideal for the beach, but there are opportunities for improvement in certain areas.

The hotel has a lovely rustic charm but lacks luxurious touches. The service was extremely helpful, especially with the great beach location, though improvements could be made. The dining experience was satisfactory, and the facilities had some positives and negatives to consider.

My stay at the hotel was overall pleasant. The rooms, while not super luxurious, were immaculate, beautiful, and comfortable. The service, though a bit disappointing at first, turned around as the manager eventually accommodated our needs. The location, particularly great for the beach, added to the experience. The breakfast in the morning was a bit underwhelming, but the fresh farm-to-table products were a nice touch. The facilities were decent, though not top-notch.

This hotel is a gem! It offers a lovely and cozy atmosphere, ideal for those who appreciate a more rustic charm. While the rooms are not super luxurious, they are comfortable and clean, providing a nice retreat. The service is friendly and welcoming, although some improvements can be made in terms of room maintenance. The location is convenient with easy access to the beach and nearby attractions. The dining experience, although limited, offers some tasty options. Overall, this hotel offers good value for money.

I loved the hotel's rustic charm and comfortable rooms, but some areas need maintenance. The service was accommodating, although improvements could be made with enthusiasm. The location was great, easily accessible down the street. The dining experience was tiring but offers homemade dishes. The facilities are decent, needing some updates for an even better experience.